Dental Implants vs Dentures: Which Suits You?
Illinois practices that publish prices charge $2,712 to $3,600 for one implant with its crown, against $300 to $1,205 for a denture on one arch. Implants stay fixed and last longer; dentures are faster, need no surgery unless teeth must come out first, and Illinois Medicaid covers them for adults. Here is which fits which situation.
Short answer: Implants suit you if you want teeth that stay fixed, have healthy gums and enough jawbone, and can spend several months and a few thousand dollars per tooth. Dentures suit you if you need to replace many teeth quickly or on a tight budget, and a lower denture held by two implants is the middle road that experts call the first choice when every lower tooth is gone.
| What you compare | Dental implants | Dentures |
|---|---|---|
| Published Illinois price | $2,712 to $3,600 for one implant with its crown | $300 to $1,205 per arch (upper or lower) |
| How long it lasts | 96.4% of implants still in place after 10 years (2019 review of 18 studies) | Check for replacement once a denture is over 5 years old (American College of Prosthodontists) |
| Time to finish | Many months, with healing between stages | A few visits for impressions, a try-in and adjustments |
| Surgery | Yes, to place the implant in the jawbone | No, unless teeth need removing first |
| Who does it | A surgeon, periodontist or trained general dentist places it; a general dentist or prosthodontist fits the tooth | A general dentist or prosthodontist |
| Medicare and Illinois Medicaid | Original Medicare does not cover them; Illinois Medicaid's dental chart does not list them | Original Medicare does not cover them; Illinois Medicaid covers adult dentures, once every 5 years |
Dental implants or dentures: which suits you?
Which one suits you comes down to three things: how many teeth you are replacing, the health of your gums and jawbone, and how much time and money you can give it. Neither option wins for everyone, so this page sets them side by side and shows which fits which situation.
You are not alone in weighing this. In the University of Michigan National Poll on Healthy Aging (published March 2020), 46% of adults aged 65 to 80 had missing teeth with no denture or implant, and 24% wore dentures.
An implant is a titanium or zirconia post placed in the jawbone that holds a crown, a bridge or a denture. A denture is a removable set of teeth on a base that rests on your gums. A full denture replaces every tooth in an arch; a partial clips onto the teeth you still have. For prices in more detail, read our guides to dental implants and dentures.
A plain rule to start: if one tooth is missing and the rest are healthy, an implant usually fits best. If most or all teeth in an arch are going, start with dentures and ask whether two implants can hold the lower one firm. You can browse all dental treatments compared for other choices, and people weighing this often also read veneers vs bonding, veneers vs crowns and zirconia vs porcelain crowns.
How do dental implant and denture prices compare in Illinois?
Per arch, a basic denture costs a fraction of one implant: published Illinois prices start at $300 to $447 for a basic denture, against $2,712 to $3,600 for a single implant with its crown. Few practices publish any price at all; only 52 of the 205 leading Illinois practices we checked show one, as our dental price transparency report explains.
The figures below are the prices we found on Illinois practice websites, checked on 2 November 2026. They are self-pay or plan prices before insurance.
| Practice | Treatment | Published price | What the price covers | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Comprehensive Dental & Implant Center, Chicago | Single implant with crown | $3,600 | Self-pay price for patients without dental insurance | practice website |
| Affordable Dentures & Implants, Forsyth | Single tooth implant with crown | $2,712 | $113 a month for 24 months at 0% APR, no down payment, for qualified buyers | office price list |
| Affordable Dentures & Implants, Forsyth | Implant to hold a denture, each | $1,344 | $56 a month for 24 months at 0% APR | office price list |
| Affordable Dentures & Implants, Forsyth | Denture, one arch | From $447, $835 or $1,205 | Economy, EconomyPlus and Premium grades | office price list |
| Aspen Dental, Alton | Basic denture | $300 to $400 | Price for members of its savings plan, which starts at $49 a year | savings plan page |
Read the totals, not the monthly figure. A full arch of implants needs several posts plus a fixed bridge, so it costs many times one implant, while a full denture is priced per arch. Extractions, bone grafts and scans are often extra on both sides; Affordable Dentures & Implants in Forsyth lists routine extractions from $109 a tooth with a denture package.
When you are ready to compare providers, see dental implant dentists in Illinois, or the shortlists of the best dental implant dentists in Elgin, Illinois and the best dental implant dentists in Downers Grove, Illinois.
How long do dental implants and dentures last?
Implants last longer: in a 2019 systematic review in the Journal of Dentistry by Howe, Keys and Richards, 96.4% of implants were still in place after 10 years across 18 studies. Dentures wear out sooner, and the American College of Prosthodontists says a denture in use for more than 5 years should be checked for replacement (position reaffirmed October 2018).
A surviving implant still needs care. A 2015 review by Derks and Tomasi found gum inflammation around implants in about 43% of patients and peri-implantitis, which destroys bone around the post, in about 22%. Daily cleaning and regular checkups are what keep an implant in the first group.
The tooth on top wears separately. An implant usually carries a dental crown, and that crown can chip or wear and be replaced without removing the post. Denture teeth are acrylic or porcelain and wear down, and your gums and jawbone keep changing shape under a denture, so it loosens over time and needs a reline or a new set.
Clenching and grinding shorten both. Grinding overloads implant crowns and wears denture teeth flat, so if you grind at night, ask about a night guard before you choose.
How do dental implants and dentures feel and look?
Implants feel and work most like your own teeth because they are fixed in the bone; dentures rest on your gums and take weeks of practice to eat and speak with. Both can look natural when the shade and shape are planned well.
| Daily life | Dental implants | Dentures |
|---|---|---|
| Feel | Fixed in place; no plate over the palate | Rest on the gums; a loose fit causes sores and needs a reline |
| Look | A crown made to match the teeth beside it | A full set of teeth and pink base, shaded to your face |
| Care at home | Brush and floss like natural teeth | Take out, rinse after meals, brush daily, keep moist overnight |
| Eating | Soft foods while each stage heals, then most foods | Soft foods while you learn; hard and sticky foods stay harder |
Care is the biggest daily difference. Mayo Clinic's denture care advice (January 2024) says to brush dentures daily with a soft brush, soak them overnight so they keep their shape, and avoid hot water, bleach and whitening toothpaste.
Plan your shade before either is made. Implant crowns and denture teeth do not lighten with whitening, so whiten your natural teeth first and match the new teeth to the result. A chipped denture tooth can usually be repaired in a dental lab, while a chipped implant crown often needs a new crown.
Which red flags should you check for dental implants and dentures?
The biggest red flag is a price or a plan given before anyone has examined you and taken X-rays or a scan. Fear of being upsold is common, and these checks protect you from it on either side.
Warning
- A low headline price that leaves out parts. One Elgin practice, Mahairi Dental Center, advertises a $499 single implant that, by its own terms, excludes the abutment and the crown. Ask for the total for the finished tooth.
- No written treatment plan. Get each step, each fee, the materials and the number of visits on paper before you sign.
- Pressure to sign the same day, or a discount that expires before you can get a second opinion.
- No follow-up terms. Ask what adjustments, relines or repairs cost in the first year, and who pays if an implant fails to heal.
- Specialist claims you cannot check. In Illinois only a dentist licensed in a specialty can advertise as a specialist, under the Illinois Dental Practice Act.
- Financing quoted as a monthly figure only. Ask for the total, the APR and the number of payments.
Which should you choose, dental implants or dentures, by situation?
Match the option to your situation: implants for single gaps in a healthy mouth, dentures for many missing teeth or a tight budget, and implant-held dentures when a lower denture will not stay put.
| Your situation | Usually fits | Why |
|---|---|---|
| One missing tooth, healthy teeth either side | Implant | No need to file down neighboring teeth, as a bridge would |
| Several teeth missing in one arch | Partial denture, or a bridge on implants | A partial costs far less; implants are fixed but need surgery on each site |
| No lower teeth and a loose lower denture | Denture held by two implants | Experts in the York Consensus Statement call it the first choice for a toothless lower jaw |
| Tight budget or no dental insurance | Denture now | Implants can be added later to hold the denture in place |
| Adult on Illinois Medicaid | Denture | Adult dentures are covered once every 5 years; implants are not on the covered list |
| You smoke or have a condition that slows bone healing | Talk it through before choosing implants | Mayo Clinic lists both as reasons an implant can fail to heal |
The two-implant advice comes from the York Consensus Statement, published in the British Dental Journal in August 2009. Mayo Clinic's dental implant surgery guide (October 2024) says implants suit people with a fully grown jaw, enough bone or a graft, healthy gums, no tobacco use and several months to give.
On coverage, Medicare.gov says Original Medicare does not cover dentures or implants in most cases. Illinois Medicaid added adult dentures in 2018 with a limit of one set every 5 years, under the state plan amendment approved by CMS; our Illinois Medicaid dental guide explains how to use it.
How we compared dental implants and dentures
We compared both options on the same rows, using dated clinical sources and the prices Illinois practices publish on their own websites. No practice paid to appear, and the practices named here are shown only because they publish a price.
- American College of Prosthodontists, position statement on the frequency of denture replacement, reaffirmed 30 October 2018
- Howe, Keys and Richards, Long-term (10-year) dental implant survival, Journal of Dentistry, 2019
- Derks and Tomasi, Peri-implant health and disease, Journal of Clinical Periodontology, 2015
- Thomason and others, York Consensus Statement, British Dental Journal, 22 August 2009
- Mayo Clinic, Dental implant surgery, 23 October 2024, and Denture care, 19 January 2024
- Medicare.gov, Dental services coverage, checked 2 November 2026
- CMS, Illinois state plan amendment 18-0011, approved 17 September 2018
- University of Michigan, National Poll on Healthy Aging, 23 March 2020
- Illinois practice websites named in the price table, checked 2 November 2026
